Here is an article from the Heritage Foundation that tackles the issue of if Korea should be entered into the US Visa Waiver Program (VWP). Here is why Korea currently is not eligible for the VWP:
The ROK is currently ineligible for the VWP because the refusal rate for nonimmigrant visas for its citizens exceeds the 3 percent maximum allowed under the VWP. The ROK’s refusal rate currently hovers just below 4 percent. [1] Because South Korea is not a VWP member, South Koreans must endure a complicated and protracted process to obtain a tourist or business visa, which has unfortunately contributed to growing animosity towards the United States.
The Heritage Foundation thinks this issue contributes to anti-Americanism in Korea. Trust me, we could enter Korea into the VWP tomorrow and it would change nothing here about the image of the United States. What I’m most concerned about with this issue is fair play with other countries. If the State Department drops it’s standards for VWP for Korea why couldn’t other countries like Pakistan demand the same treatment for helping the US in the War on Terror? Here is the Heritage Foundations arguement for Korea entering the VWP:
These unwieldy visa regulations are a stark con?trast to the strong U.S.–ROK military alliance and trade relationship. The ROK has proven itself a staunch ally of the United States by deploying 3,600 troops to Iraq, the second largest non-U.S. coalition presence after Great Britain. South Korea is also the United States’ seventh-largest trading partner, accounting for more than $70 billion in total bilateral trade in 2004.
The ROK-US alliance at the military level I would agree is still strong. US and ROK Army officers and soldiers work well together, no doubt it. However, at the political level is where there are major problems in the US-ROK alliance. Also, Korea maybe the 3rd largest troop dispatch to Iraq, but what are they doing? Countries with less troops are doing more than Korea. Plus an alliance is a two way street. Korea sends 3,000+ soldiers to sit on an airfield in Northern Iraq every year to fix toilets and play Starcraft and the US sends 32,000+ soldiers to Korea every year to dance on top of taxi cabs. It all evens out to me.
Then the fact that Korea is the 7th largest trading partner does not hold much weight with me either because the majority of the trade is going from Korea to the US and the American goods coming into Korea are heavily taxed making most American products here something only the wealthy can afford creating a large trade imbalance between the two countries.
The visa requirements, while arguably necessary due to heightened security concerns in the post-9/11 world, have regrettably discouraged Koreans from vis?iting the United States. Although the total number of Korean tourists traveling abroad in 2004 increased by 27 percent from the previous year, the number of South Korean visitors to the United States decreased by 5 percent, and the number of South Koreans applying for nonimmigrant visas to the United States dropped from 420,000 in 2003 to 360,000 in 2004.
I don’t foresee the US tourism industry collapsing because a few less Koreans are going to the Grand Canyon. I think the US tourism industry will be alright.
The onerous process of obtaining a visa has also inadvertently aggravated anti-American senti?ments, thwarting Washington’s public diplomacy efforts in South Korea.
Like I said before bending the rules and letting Korea into the VWP will not significantly change the image of America here in Korea. Finally the Hertitage Foundation thinks the VWP would reduce the work load of the US Embassy in Seoul.
These requirements have made the U.S. consular section in Seoul the largest U.S. nonimmigrant visa processing post in the world—processing an aver?age of nearly 2,000 visas per day and straining the embassy’s financial and human resources.
If you ever get a chance swing by the US Embassy sometime and see what a mad house that place is every day. The line to get in there stretches for quite a distance. I always find it interesting about how the same people who complain about the US all the time are probably the same people standing in line for two hours to just get in the US Embassy to apply for a Visa to come to the US.
The Heritage Foundation makes a good arguement but some of the points they bring up are common points many Koreans bring up about how they support America, but once you closely scrutinize them the contributions though commendable are not as noteworthy as one is led to believe. I’m of the opinion that the US has a system in place with a set standard. Meet the standard if you want in.
This issue is made to look like America is the bad guys for not letting the Korea into the VWP. It is not just Koreans. Anyone who doesn’t meet the standard is not allowed in. Korea is not being singled out or prevented from entering the VWP, they just need to work harder to meet the standards set by US law. I don’t see any reason why we should bend the rules solely for Korea. If Korea meets the standards then I say let them in and end the chaos at the US Embassy. I’m sure the employees there would be greatly relieved along with everyone else that has ever had to wait in a line there for two hours.