The Show Must Go On, but Not the Summit
I think Nomad is on to something with the fact that the North Korean Arirang Mass Games are going to continue despite the flooding, but the Second Inter-Korea Summit has been delayed. Someone else who is on to something is OFK who finds the damage statistics from the flooding very suspicious:
Beyond that, things are less certain. North Korea officially claims that the floods killed 300 people and left 300,000 homeless. Those figures don’t jibe with each other. In a mountainous and underdeveloped country, any disaster large enough to make more than a quarter of a million people homeless — the size of a small city — would have claimed more lives.
OFK also links to this Bloomberg report that offers plenty dubious statistics as well:
The UN said today that 58,000 homes were damaged in the flooding, 50 percent of the country’s health clinics were destroyed, and as much as 70 percent of arable land was under water. More than 800 public buildings, 540 bridges, 70 sections of railway and 500 high-voltage power towers also were destroyed, according to the UN. [Bloomberg]
It doesn’t make sense that the Arirang Mass Games would continue if these statistics that represent a nation wide mass disaster are true. That is because these statistics are probably not true and the flooding is being used as a convenient excuse to delay the summit to October so it has maximum impact on the South Korean presidential election, allow NK to have more time to make demands, ask for increased international aid that will not be monitored, as well as exact maximum propaganda value from the summit:
Moreover, October is a month for a series of celebrations in the North. October 8 marks the 10th anniversary of Kim Jong Il’s inauguration as the Secretary General of the Korean Workers’ Party (KWP), while the 9th marks the first anniversary of the country’s nuclear test, and the 10th is the 62nd anniversary of the foundation of the KWP. If the South Korean president’s visit to Pyongyang coincides with these dates, North Korean propagandists could likely attempt to make the most of it. [Donga Ilbo]
Finally the biggest reason for playing up the flooding damage is that President Roh can use it as cover when he locks South Korea into an extended bribery yearly humanitarian aid package to North Korea. He can claim it is the "North Korean Marshall Plan" to rebuild the country after the flooding. Talk about a well time flood. I bet Roh and Kim were both jumping at the chance to delay the summit when the rain started falling.


I notice you didn't mention the elections. There have been a few who have stated that the floods will bolster support for a progressive candidate by both candid photo opportunities and greater S.Korean empathy for the North as pictures of the homeless and hurt are spread…
But maybe you think as I say over at my new site (shameless plug, please excuse) http://www.koreanunification.net … it had better be one VERY SPECIAL SUMMIT to bolster a progressive candidate at this stage of the game…
[…] Update: Another interesting view over at ROK Drop. […]
I did say in my posting that moving it so October is being used to impact the election. NK can play play up all the damage of the flood for the next month and then the summit happens Roh offers this huge pay out to Kim and Kim plays nice for the cameras and thanks Roh and makes vague promises he never intends to keep. That is pretty much what I think the story line for the summit will be.
I don't think it will be enough to catapult any of the leftist candidate past Lee Myung-bak. Lee Myung-bak has centered his campaign around the economy while the leftists are offering more sunshine. People seem tired of sunshine and more concerned about the state of the economy which is where Lee is heads and shoulders above any of the leftist candidates.
By the way I have linked to your site on my link menu after having recently discovered it. It is quite good and I will be reading often.
I think the most interesting aspect of the floods is the level of North Korean openess regarding the damage. There has been wide coverage on North Korean TV, which will inevitably filter through to ROK TV. The floods have been continually compared to those of the 1990s, which resulted in food shortages and ultimately substantial empathy in the ROK media – ultimately leading to Sunshine. Is the North trying to spur on empathy to keep Sunshine… or am I just a cynic?
They are trying to get empathy to provide cover for Roh to give them the huge payout during the upcoming summit. They need to do this to hedge their bets against Lee Myung-bak possibly altering long term payouts to the North if he gets elected.
I think if Lee is elected you will not see so much money going up North because of Lee's ideas for massive public works projects in South Korea which he is campaigning on. I think Lee's canal idea is far fetched but I think spending all the money it is going to take to build his canal is better than sending billions of unaccounted for money to North Korea which is what I believe Roh is going to try and lock the country into for a number of years during the upcoming summit.
The games must go on…
A summit between North Korea and South Korea has been postponed due to recent floods. A gymnastics tournament continues on in the DPRK. What is wrong with this picture?…
[…] The Show Must Go On, but Not the Summit — [GI Korea] Published by GI KoreaAugust 22, 2007 in Inter-Korean Issues and North Korea. 5 Comments I think Nomad is on to something with the fact that the North Korean Arirang Mass Games are going to continue despite the flooding, but the Second Inter-Korea Summit has been delayed. Someone else who is on to something is OFK who finds the damage statistics from the flooding very suspicious: […]
[…] at ROK Drop thinks Nomad is on to something. It doesn’t make sense that the Arirang Mass Games would continue if […]
[…] the floods this month and updated their damage assessment across the country from the floods. I am still maintaining that these floods are being hyped by the North Koreans to gain additional aid money. Look at how […]