The “Great Dokto Crisis of March 2005” continues to be blown way out of proportion. The Dokto issue has now been featured in the NY Times. The NY Times overall takes the Korean side of this issue by bringing up Japan’s past war time atrocities and relating those to the current Japanese government.
For older South Koreans, like Mr. Heo, the bitterness of the past resurfaced. His father had told him of working in a stable where he watched Japanese soldiers eat.
“The Japanese would say Koreans work hard only if they are hungry,” Mr. Heo recalled his father saying. “So when they finished eating, they would overturn the table, and my father would have to pick up the scraps.”
For young South Koreans, who had grown up consuming Japanese anime and music, the dispute suddenly changed their view of Japan. At the J-Pop section in the Kyobo Bookstore here today, Lee You Mi, 18, a college student, was looking at a CD by a Japanese singer, Mika Nakashima.
“My image of Japan as an open country has changed to that of a closed country with remnants of imperialism,” Ms. Lee said.
The dispute comes as Japan, urged on by the United States, has been building up its military and taking a hard line against China and North Korea. A nationalism not previously seen in postwar Japan has emerged, with Mr. Koizumi unapologetically praying at Yasukuni Shrine, where 14 Class A war criminals are enshrined, and with teachers in Tokyo being punished for not forcing their students to stand and sing the national anthem during graduation ceremonies. It was also disclosed recently that senior members of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party pressed the public broadcaster, NHK, to soften a 2001 documentary on Japan’s wartime sex slaves.
The NY Times seems to also think that the “Great Dokto Crisis” will cause Korea to unite with North Korea and China to oppose Japan:
“Japan should understand that its actions regarding Tokdo have regional repercussions,” said Park Cheol Hee, a specialist on Japanese politics and diplomacy at Seoul National University, in an interview on Monday. “If South Korean-Japan relations become twisted, the result will be that South Korea and North Korea will become united against Japan. And as China and Korea share the same historical perspective toward Japan, the unintended consequence will bring China and the Korean peninsula against Japan.”
The NY Times article concludes with this:
“I strongly urge the Japanese foreign office and Japanese government to take a much more independent and much more positive policy toward Asia,” Makoto Taniguchi, a former Japanese ambassador to the United Nations who now teaches at universities in Japan and China, told reporters in Tokyo last week. “Otherwise, there is no future for Japan. Japan will be totally neglected in Asia, and, in the future, if Japan’s position and economic power go down, what is its use to the U.S.?”
Some how I don’t think the “Great Dokto Crisis” will cause Japan to lose political, cultural, or economic influence over the long run. I think if Japan is smart about this, which is debatable since they caused this crisis to begin with; that they should just keep their mouths shut and the Koreans will naturally forget about it and the special interest groups will move on to bashing English teachers or GI’s to get people pissed off again.
I do have to say that we, the army, have gone almost a year now since the “Great Shinchon Stabbing” and nobody talks about that any more. Unfortunately we are due for somebody to do something stupid again. It seems like every year around this time somebody does something stupid that gets people pissed off at the army over the summer and then everyone forgets about it come fall time. Hopefully this year we can break that trend. However, with 32,000 USFK forces on the peninsula going out more because of the warm weather, odds are somebody will do something stupid. I just hope Koreans don’t set themselves on fire or chop their fingers off over it.