Are the values of today’s US military becoming incompatible with Catholic teachings? Here is one opinion on this issue:
“It is therefore with sadness that I say today’s soldiers, are in general, but with definite exceptions, a disgrace to their predecessors. The world over, this once honorable institution is becoming a den of sex maniacs, sadists, and hedonists, much as the world in general is.”
My instincts have always been pro-military. My grandfather was a U.S. Army Captain and WW-II veteran, and he was one of the best men I have ever known. My great-uncle also served proudly in the same conflict. These men have been profoundly influential in my own development, and they would be shocked and disappointed to hear me say anything against the military as an institution. We need our military, and we need our men-at-arms to do unpleasant things. But I am beginning to wonder whether American military life isn’t becoming radically incompatible with Catholicism.
I disagree with the author’s point of view on this. The author believes that today’s military is over sexed, anti-gay, and glamorizes killing compared to prior generations of soldiers in the US military. I tend to think each generation of soldiers had it’s own problems unique to its times. Today is no different.
During World War II the military was still a racist and sexist institution and even had segregated military units. Isn’t this more morally reprehensible than some kid today listening to Heavy Metal music and with a Maxim picture hanging up in his room? Plus the World War II generation of soldiers also took part in their fair share of prostitution during the war and especially during the occupations of Germany and Japan. Is this not also incompatible with Catholicism?
Let’s look at Vietnam. During the Vietnam War the military made strides at improving the racist culture in the military. At least their wasn’t segregated units any more, however the civil rights movement began during this time and racial tension was still very real within the ranks. Also during the Vietnam War soldiers also had their fair share of prostitutes, foul language, nudy mags, etc. The one thing that was unique to the Vietnam War was the amount of drug abuse. Not that drugs haven’t been used before, but during the Vietnam War they were used heavily which reflected the culture of drug abuse in America at the time.
Now let’s look at today’s military. You have an all volunteer force which means you probably are not going to have to many Harvard graduates in uniform. So basically the majority of the soldiers are from the middle to lower middle class of American society. What is prevalent today in those classes: Rap music, rock music, Maxim, Hollywood movies, Playstation, Internet, etc. Is it no surprise that soldiers bring these values with them into the military?
Let’s look what we don’t have in today’s military. The Army has made huge strides against racism and sexism. There are times when I am standing in formation and looking around, I am just amazed by the different ethnicities represented in the formation all working together for a common cause. Plus each one of them has an equal opportunity to improve themselves, seek promotions, and additional responsibility not hindered by the color of their skin, sex, ethnicity, or religious background. I’m willing to bet there is not a more integrated institution in America than the US military.
Today’s military is still battling drug abuse like the rest of society, but the monthly urinalysis program has allowed the military to greatly reduce the amount of drug abuse since the Vietnam War by identifying drug abusers and either getting them treatment or removing them from the military all together. Also today’s soldiers are more educated compared to prior generations of American soldiers. The vast majority have graduated from high school and many have proficient technical and computer skills before they even enter the military. Plus once they are in the military the military offers many opportunities for soldiers to take college course and advance their education.
Today’s military does have its problems in regards to sexual assault which stems from the fact that the military is now well integrated between both sexes and that makes sexual assault a more prevalent problem today than compared to earlier generations of soldiers who served in mainly all male militaries.
Soldiers today also listen to rap and heavy metal music, read Playboy, hang up Maxim pictures in their rooms, and play violent video games, but they didn’t learn this by coming into the military. They got taught this by the society that put them in the military to begin with. But I will take these soldiers over a drafted, racist, sexist, and drug abusing military any day.
So is Catholicism compatible with today’s military compared to prior generations of soldiers? I think so, but those who think prior generations of soldiers were better may need to ask themselves if they are really offended by the nudy mags, foul language, and the rap music of today’s soldiers or more offended by the racism, drug abuse, and gender inequality of prior generations?
Hat Tip: Katolic Shinja